SHIA RAWAAFIZ KE DHOKEBAAZI AUR FAREB AUR ILM-E-HADEES KE SAATH CHHED CHHAAD

SHIA RAWAAFIZ KE DHOKEBAAZI AUR FAREB

AUR ILM-E-HADEES KE SAATH CHHED CHHAAD

Shia Rawaafiz ,Syyedina Hazrat Ammar Bin Yaasir Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Ki Shaahadt Waali Hadees Ke Saath Chhed Chad Aur Tod Marod Kar Awaam Ke Saamne Pesh Karke Amirul Momineen Syyedina Hazrat Amir Muawiya Ibn-E-Abu Sufyaan Radiallaho Ta’ala Anhuma Ko Ma’azallah Baaghi Saabit Karne Me Lage Rahte Hai Aur Bholi Bhaali Awaam Jinhey Na Hadees Ka Usool Maaloom Na Qawaneen Unko Yeh Shia Rafzi Gumraah Karne Ki Koshish Karte Hai, Aur Daleel Ke Taur Par Bukhari Shareef Ki Yeh Hadees Pesh Karte Hai :-

🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻🔻

Huzoorﷺ  Ne Hazrat Ammaar Bin Yaasir Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Ko

Dekha Ke Masjid-E-Nabawi Ki Taameer Ke

Dauran Baaki Log 1 Eent (Brick) Uthakar Rakh

Rahe Hain, Jab Ke Hazrat Ammaar 2 Eentey (Bricks)

Utha Rahe Hain... Ye Manzar Dekh'kar

Huzoorﷺ  Ne Hazrat Ammaar Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho

Ke Jism Se Mitti Jhaadi Aur Farmaya ::

" Aye Ammaar Allah Ki Rehmat Ho Tujh Par..

Tujhe Ek Baaghi Giroh Qatl Karega...

Tu Unhey Jannat Ki Taraf Bula Raha

Hoga Or Woh Tujhe Jahunnum Ki Taraf."

_

Reference :: (Shahi Bukhari , Hadees No. 2812)

 

Phir Yeh Shia Rawaafiz Dhoka Dete Huwe Kahtey Hai Ki Yeh Riwaayat Bukhari Shareef Ki Hai  Aur Ismein Do- Tokk Andaaz Me Is Baat Ki Saraahat Hai Ki Syyedina Hazrat Amir Muawiya Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho  Aur Aapke Tamam Lashkari Baaghi Hai (Ma’azallah) ,Kyunke Huzoorﷺ Ki Peshangoyi Unhi Par Saadiq Aayi,Lihaaza Syyedina Hazrat Ammaar Bin Yaasir Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Ke Qatl Ke Jurm Wajah Se Yeh Hazraat Baaghi Qaraar Paaye ,Isliye Unhe Baaghi Qaraar Na Dena Huzoorﷺ Ke Irshaad Ko Jhuthlaana Hai.

 

JAWAB:-

Sabse Pehli Baat Ki In Shia Rawaafiz Ne Aadhi Hadees Pesh Ki  Q Dhoke Se Kaam Lena Inki Puraani Aadat Hai Lihaaza Aaiye Sabse Pehle Puri Hadees Sanad Ke Saath Dekh Lijiye, Q Ki Koi Bhi Hadees Ki Sehat Wa Mazbooti Uske Raawiyo Ke Ahwaal Ke Zariye Pata Lagaya Jata Hai Lihaza Puri Hadees Dekhiye :-

BAAB:- باب مَسْحِ الْغُبَارِ عَنِ النَّاسِ، فِي السَّبِيلِ

 

حَدَّثَنَا إِبْرَاهِيمُ بْنُ مُوسَى ، أَخْبَرَنَا عَبْدُ الْوَهَّابِ ، حَدَّثَنَا خَالِدٌ ، عَنْ عِكْرِمَةَ ، أَنَّ ابْنَ عَبَّاسٍ قَالَ لَهُ ، وَلِعَلِيِّ بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ : ائْتِيَا أَبَا سَعِيدٍفَاسْمَعَا مِنْ حَدِيثِهِ فَأَتَيْنَاهُ ، وَهُوَ وَأَخُوهُ فِي حَائِطٍ لَهُمَا يَسْقِيَانِهِ فَلَمَّا رَآنَا جَاءَ فَاحْتَبَى وَجَلَسَ ، فَقَالَ : كُنَّا نَنْقُلُ لَبِنَ الْمَسْجِدِ لَبِنَةً لَبِنَةً ، وَكَانَ عَمَّارٌ يَنْقُلُ لَبِنَتَيْنِ لَبِنَتَيْنِ ، فمر بِهِ النَّبِيُّ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ ، وَمَسَحَ عَنْ رَأْسِهِ الْغُبَارَ ، وَقَالَ : " وَيْحَ عَمَّارٍ تَقْتُلُهُ الْفِئَةُ الْبَاغِيَةُ عَمَّارٌ يَدْعُوهُمْ إِلَى اللَّهِ ، وَيَدْعُونَهُ إِلَى النَّارِ " .

TARJAMA:-

 Hamsein  Ibraahim Bin Musaa Ne Bayaan Kiya  ,Kaha Humko Abdul Wahaab Ne Khabar Di, Kaha Hamsein Khalid Ne Bayan Kiya Ikrama Se Ke “Syyedina Hazrat Ibne Abbaas Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho  Ne “Ikrama”   Aur   “Ali Bin Abdullah “   Se  Farmaaya  Ke Tum Dono Syyedina Hazrat Abu Saeed  Khudri Al-Khazraji Al-Ansari  Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho  Ke Paas Jaao Aur  Unsein Hadees Ka Sama’a Karo ,Pass Hum Dono (Ikrama Aur Ali Bin Abdullah)  Unki Khidmat Me Haazir Huwe Jabki Woh Apne Bhai Ke Saath Baagh Ko Paani De Rahe The ,Jab Unhone Hamein Dekha To Hamaare Paas Tashreef  Le Aaye Aur  (Chaadr Odh Kar) Got Maar Kar Baith Gaye , Phir  Farmaaya Ke  Jab Masjid-E-Nabwi Ki Taameer Ho Rahi Thi  To Hum Ek Ek Eent Uthaakar Laate The  Lekin Syyedina Hazrat Ammaar Bin Yaasir Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Do Do Eent Uthaakar Laate The Jab Nabi-E-Kareem  ﷺ Unke Paas Se Guzrey To Unke Sar Ka Ghoobaar Jhaadte Huwe  Farmaaya :- Ammaar Ki Us Haalat Par Afsos Hai Ke Unko Bbaaghiyo Ka Giroh Qatl Karega Yeh To Unhe Allah Ki Taraf Bulaayenge Aur Woh Unko Jahannam Ki Taraf.

(Sahih Bukhari,Hadees No:-2812)

Aapne Dekh Li Hogi Puri Hadees Magar Shia Rafzi Puri Hadees Nahi Dikhaayega kyun Ki Ussein Unka Jhooth Saamne Aa Jaayega Lihaza Unka Yeh Hadees Pesh Karke Syyedina Hazrat Amir Muawiya Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Aur Unke Lashkariyo Ko Baaghi Saabit Karna Yeh Mahaz Ek Ilzaam Hai.

 

Pehli Baat Ke Yeh Ilzaam Us Waqt Sahih Hoga Jab Iski Koi Taaweel Na Ki Jaa Sakti Ho Lekin Yeh Agar Sahih Na Ho To Phir Usse Istadlaal Durust Na Hoga.

“والامر کذلک فان فی سنده ضعفا ليسقط الاستدلال به “

Tarjama- Aur Chunke Uski Sanad Me Za’af (ضعف) Hai Isliye Is Riwaayat Se Istadlaal Saaqit (ساقط) Ho Gaya , Rahi Yeh Baat Ki Ibn-E-Hannaan Ne Riwaayat-E-Bukhari Ki Tauseeq (توثيق) Ki Hai To Hum Kahtey Hai Ke Unki Tauseeq (توثيق) ,Uski Taz’eef(تضعيف)  Karne Waale Hazraat Ke Hum’palla Nahi Ho Sakti, Kyunki  Ibn-E-Hannaan Tauseeq (توثيق) Me Bahot Sust Shumaar Hotey Hai.

(Tatheer Al-Jinaan,Page-35)

Is Hadees Ki Sanad Me Mandarja-Zel Raawi Hai :-

Musaddad,Abdul Azeez Bin Mukhtar, Khaalid Al-Khalda’a, Aur Ikrama ,Aur Ab Inpar Olama-E-Hadees Ka Tabsara Mulaahiza Kijiye:-

(1)          Musaddad- Syyedina Imam Zahbi Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Iske Mutaalliq Likhte Hai Ke

“قال القطانی فيه تساهل” Ya’ani Qattaani Ne Kaha ,Musaddad Me Tasaahil(تساهل) Paaya Jaata Hai.(Mizaanul Aitedaal,Vol-3,Page-162)

Aur Mohaddiseen Ke Nazdeek Tasaahil(تساهل) Ki Sifat Riwaayat Ko Na-Qaabil-E-Aitbaar Thehraati Hai .

 

(2)          Abdul Azeez Bin Mukhtar:- Syyedina Imam Zahbi Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Likhte Hai , Ahmad Bin Zuhair  Kahtey Hai “انه ليس بشىء” Ya’ani Woh Kuchh Bhi Nahi.

Shaikh-Ul-Islam Syyedina Hazrat Imam Ibne Hajr Al-Asqalaani Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho  Likhte Hai Ki Ibne Abi Khaseema, Ibne Mo’een Se Riwaayat Karte Hai Ke ليس بشىء Ya’ani Yeh Kuchh Bhi Nahi .

(Tahzeeb At-Tahzeeb,Vol-6,Page-356)

(Mizaanul Aitedaal,Vol-2,Page-139)

 

(3) Khaalid Al-Khalda’a :- Syyedina Imam Zahbi Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Likhte Hai Ki

 Abu Haatim Ne Kaha “لا یحتج به” Ya’ani “Yeh Qaabil-E-Ihtijaaj Nahi Hai “

Syyedina Hazrat Imam Ahmad Bin Hanbal Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Kahtey Hai Ki Ibne Aliyaa Se Is Hadees Ke Muta’alliq Daryaaft Kiya Ke Khaalid Uski Riwaayat Karta Raha Aur Hamnein Uski Taraf Koi Tawajjo Nahi Di . “ضعف ابن علية امر خالد” Ya’ani  “Ibne Aliyaa Ne Khalid Ko Za’eef Kaha Hai .

(Mizaanul Aitedaal,Vol-1,Page-301)

 

(4)          Ikrama :- Syyedina Hazrat Ibne Abbas Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Ka Yeh Ghulam Tha, Iska Naam “Ikrama Al-Bariri Abu Abdullah Al-Madani”  Hai.

Shaikh-Ul-Islam Syyedina Hazrat Imam Ibne Hajr Al-Asqalaani Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho  Likhte Hai :-

Yahya Baka’a Kahtey Hai Maine Syyedina Hazrat Ibne Omar Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Apne Shaagird “Naa’fe” Se Yeh Kahtey Huwe Suna:-

“Aye Naa’fe ! Tujhpar Afsos , Allah Se Daro , “لا تکذب علی کما کذب عکرمة علی ابن عباس’ Ya,Ani

“Mujh Par Jhuth Na Baandhna Jaisa Ke Ikrama Ne Syyedina Hazrat Ibne Abbaas Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Par Baandha Hai.”

(Tahzeeb At-Tahzeeb,Vol-7,Page-260)

Syyedina Hazrat Imam Zahbi Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Likhte Hai Ki “Abdullah Bin Haaris” , “Ali Bin Abdullah Ibne Abbaas” Ke Paas Gaye  To Dekha Ke Ikrama Darwaaze Par Bandha Hua Hai, To Main(Abdullah Bin Haaris) Ne Un(Ali Bin Abdullah Ibne Abbaas) Se  Kaha  Allah Ka Khauff Karein To Unhone Kaha “ان هذالخبیث یکذب علی ابی” Ya’ani  “Yeh (Ikrama) Khabees Mere Waalid ( Syyedina Hazrat Ibne Abbaas Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho) Par Jhooth Baandhta Hai , Mas’ab Bin Zubair Ne Kaha Ke “کان عكرمة يرى راى الخوارج” Ya’ani “Ikrama Khawaarij Ka Nazariya (Aqeedah) Rakhta Tha.

(Mizaanul Aitedaal,Page-308)

Is Tafseel Se Zer-E-Bahas Hadees Ki Riwaayat Ki Asliyat Aur Haqeeqat Aur Seerat  Wa Kirdaar Waazeh Ho Gaya Hai Jo Raawi Na-Qaabil-E-Aitbaar , ليس بشىء, Na-Qaabil-E-Ihtijaaj,Ghair Siqah,Jhoothey Aur Khaarji Ho To Unki Riwaayat Se Amirul Momineen Syyedina Hazrat Amir Muawiya Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Ke Khilaaf Istadlaal Kaise Kiya Jaa Sakta Hai ?

Lihaza Yaha Dalaail Ki Raushni Me Saaf Ho Gayi Baat Ki Yeh Riwaayat Qaabil-E-Aitbaar Nahi Lihaza Ilzaam Jhootha Saabit Hua Rafziyo Ka , Lihaaza Bholi Bhaali Awaam Inke Fareb Se Bache Warna Deen-O-Duniya Dono Barbaad Ho Jaayega.

Allah Rabbul Izzat Panjetan Pak,Khulfa-E-Raashideen, Ahlebait-E-Athaar Wa Ansaar,Syyedina Hazrat Amir Muawiya Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Aur Tamam Sahaba Karaam Radiallaho Ta’ala Anhum Ajmaeen Ka Adab Aur Mohabbat Karne Ki, Maslak-E-Alahazrat Par Qaayem-O-Daayem Rahne Ki Taufeeq Ata Farmaaye.

Aameen  Ba-Tufail Sultanul Auliya Ghausul Aazam Sheikh Abdul Qadir Jilaani Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Wa Ba-Tufail Jaddi Syyedina Pir-E-Herat Shaikhul Islam Khwaja Abdullah Al-Harwi Al-Ayyubi Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho Wa Aba-Tufail Syyedina Wa Murshidina Wa Sanadina Hazrat Tajushhariah Ash-Shah Imam Akhter Raza Khan Qadri Azhari Radiallaho Ta’ala Anho.

Taalib-E-Dua:- Mir Md Tausif Raza Qadri Razvi Al-Ayyubi